|
Impact of traditional practices on
women
First Chapter
Preliminary Session
1. Introduction of
the Organization
The Women and
Children Legal Research Foundation (WCLRF) as one of
the professional organizations in the area of women
and child right was established in the year 2002
with the efforts from a group of women lawyers in
Kabul city.
The main reason for
the establishment of WCLRF was the universal debates
made around the living situation of women and
children in Afghan society.
In all these debates
the issue of traditional practices stood as one of
the main factors for violations to the women right.
But in a war effected country like Afghanistan which
relay mainly on traditional customs and people
practice such customs as part of their believes;
there is a limited number of individuals who believe
that these customs are brining many violations to
the life of women and children in Afghanistan.
This issue was the
main reason which establish the foundation of WCLRF;
and the founders of WCLRF started working on the
above mentioned issue voluntarily, and their aim was
to primarily collect the facts and figures proving
the presence of the violation inducing traditions
which are catastrophic for women and children and
secondly they should highlight the role of
governmental institutions who are anyhow involved in
bringing the change in this regards, but now
playing the role of silent audience.
In fact WCLRF was
established to struggle against the injustice and
obstacles towards women and children rights which
needs programming in short and long term; WCLRF was
founded to provide human right defenders with
reliable documents and facts in order to prove the
traditional practices as a means of hardship towards
women and children life.
2. A bout the conference:
The last week of
November was the week to celebrate the struggles
opposing “violence against women”, which was
commemorated world wide including Afghanistan. As
mentioned, some of the traditional practices have
been known as tools for violating women rights; thus
the conference held by the WCLRF was mainly focusing
tradition induced violation against women rights.
The conference aimed to hold a national discussion
about the impact of traditional practices on women
life in order to highlight:
a) The types of
traditional practices,
b) Impact of each of
them on women’s life,
c) Methods to
prevent volitional tradition.
The conference was
financed by UNIFEM and Afghan Women Leaders Connect
and was coordinated with Ministry of Women Affairs,
Afghan Independent Human Right Commission (AIHRC),
Afghan Women Network (AWN), Foundation for Culture
and civil Society (FCCS), AREZO office in Kabul and
the distinguish individuals; Sayd Masoom Badakhsh,
Najia Hanifi, Shila Samimi, Khadija and Jawed
Danishyar.
3. Method of
Conduct:
In order to conduct
the conference effectively, a task force
committee was formed of representative from
the ministry of Women Affairs, AREZO Office and one
of the advisors from the WCLRF. The committee was
assigned for over all management and supervision of
the program.
The main
responsibility of the task force was the selection
of participants, accomplished through a few step
process. First 20 provinces were selected based on
criteria which could cover all the country, secondly
the organizations with wide coverage in the selected
provinces were contacted; in the third step,
questionnaires and nomination forms were developed
and sent out to the provinces through the selected
organizations (Afghan Independent Human right
Commission (AIHRC), Foundation for Culture and civil
Society (FCCS) and AREZO Office. (The questionnaire
is attached)
In order to have the
best participants, each province was asked to
nominate 3 candidates for each allocated seat (two
seat were allocated for each province) the nominees
were to fill out the questionnaire which had to be
reviewed by the task force in Kabul on the bases of
which the selection were made.
A total number if 60
people were nominated from 20 provinces and based on
the criteria 28 were selected, which were consisted
of following categories:
1. Representatives
from civil society, Government officials and
respective people from each province,
2. Civil society
representative and Government officials from Kabul
3- Representatives
of the related Government departments
4. Journalists
(List of
participants is attached)
The conference was
continued for three days from 22 to 24 November
2004.
The first day of the
conference mainly comprised the speeches from the
official representatives of the related
organizations aiming to clarify the consequences of
the traditional practices and the responsibility in
this regards, which was continued by discussion s
among the participants and speakers.
The second day of
the conference was allocated mainly for group works
and discussions among participants and the objective
was to provide an opportunity for exchange of
opinions and also to analyze the traditional
practices existing in different parts of the country
and also to seek solutions for such practices. The
third day of the conference which was the last day
designed mainly for drafting the conference
declaration and also to present the declaration to
press and audience from the related government
officials, also the last day of the conference we
lunched the research report on “Bad painful
Sedative” (the research report on one of the
traditional practices applied on women). During the
conference a movie and a theatrical piece were
displayed to participants about the practice of
“Bad” (exchange of women for dispute settlement) and
the issue of “stoning” (punishment for committing
adultery).
It is worth
mentioning that the declaration was announced in the
conference and was signed by all participants and
also a representative from Supreme Court signed it
on the behalf of Supreme Court. (Conference agenda
is attached)
4. Criteria for Selection of
Participants:
A set of criteria
were develop by the task force committee for
selection of participants, which are as follow:
1. The head of the
organization should not nominate her/him self;
2. The
participants should be aware of the existing
traditional practices on their neighborhood;
3. The participants
should be a well known personality in the
neighborhood;
4. Male candidates
should be a member of local councils.
5. Conference Achievements:
With the fact that
the traditional practices exist in the most parts of
the country and have their own importance among the
public and vast sections of the rural areas, are
managed by such structures; holding a national
conference and claiming that most of these
traditional practices are violating the rights of
women; in itself is a big step. Bellow is a short
summary of main achievements of the conference:
1. The Supreme Court
announced its support
for the declaration
of the conference, and their representative signed
the declaration officially,
2. The ministry of
Women Affairs has also confirm the
importance of
conducting such program and they office-
-ially signed the
declaration,
3. The public in
Kabul and other provinces appreciate the effort of
organizing such programs,
4. The issue of
traditional practices and its impact was broadcast
through the media circle; radio channels and press
and websites,
5. The declaration
of the conference was signed by participants of all
other gatherings conducted by Ministry of Women
Affairs for celebration of 25th of November and also
a representative from WCLRF was invited in all these
events to explain the findings of the conference to
participants,
6. The declaration
was confirmed by representatives from Afghan
Independent Human Right Commission (AIHRC),
Afghanistan Supreme Court, Judicial Reform
Commission (JRC) and other related government
departments and the representatives from more than
20 provinces of the country.
6. The importance of the Conference:
The conference on
the “Impact of traditional practices on Afghan
women” has proven its high importance in such a
critical time of reform and rehabilitation of the
country, which can be summarized as bellow:
a. The outcome of
the conference can be taken seriously in to account
by the JRC and other organization that are
supporting Judicial Reform process in Afghanistan in
order to bring positive changes in the legal
framework and confirm the unlawfulness of the
traditional practices violating women right as a
short term impact.
b. In the long term
perspective, as the rule of law can be applied all
over the country the informal justice (local
councils) system should be provided with a framework
of operation and there should be a mechanism of
accountability developed for the decisions taken
with the local councils.
Second Chapter
First Section
General conception
of traditional Practices and its Impact on Women

The traditional
practices has a longer age than the rule of law in
almost all societies, and once upon a time it was
known as the only source for applying rule of the
law, although there is ages of introducing the
written law to communities but still traditional
rules and practices has their own applications, and
transfer from one generation to another generation
over centuries.
Although there are a
number of traditional
practices which are
contrary to human rights
principles, there
are also a number of tradition-
-nal ractices which
form the foundation f human
right principles and
is confirmed nationally and internationally.
The participants of
the conference tried to analyze only the set of
traditional practices which is against the
principles of Islam and Human Right. So, what you
will read bellow is the summary of the discussions
and speeches of the conference with the focus on the
practices which violate women rights in Afghanistan.
1. Islam and Traditional Practices:
The
tradition means “Anana” in Arabic which is confirmed
in Quran (the holly book of Muslims). Based on
historical views when Islam emerged there were a
number of traditional practices existing in
societies contradicting Islam, but also there were a
number of practices which had nothing against Islam.
The number of
customs and practices which were not contrary to
Islam were named as “Marrof” and confirmed by
Islam*, but those practices and customs which were
against Islam were rejected by Islamic rules and
Muslims were forbidden of such practices. As an
example “burying alive the newborn girls” (the
ancient Arabs considered the birth of a baby girl as
a sign of shame so by the time a baby girl was born
they were burying her alive) and this action was
strongly condemned and prohibited by Islam.
Meanwhile there were
lots of efforts to confirm the great importance and
position of women in Muslim societies since many of
the reliable historical documents present number of
“Hadith” (speeches and guidance from Prophet
Mohammad) through which all the effort is put
together to change the mentality of the society
towards women.
For instance:
Someone went to
Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) and asked who is entitled of
respect more than every body in the world, Prophet (PBUH)
told: the Mother; the person asked the question
three times and received the same answer and in the
forth time he got this response: the Father .
It is worth
mentioning that the response given above is not a
personnel view of a writer, poet… but it is the
words said by Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) and it is
clear that what he says is the words of Quran and
Quran is the message from the God. As Quran says:
“The Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) instructs us on what he
have been instructed to say by God.”
Also in another
Hadith:
Prophet Mohammad
(PBUH) told to Omar (the second Islamic leader after
Prophet Mohammad) go and ask a person by the name of
Wais Qarani to pray for you to the God. Omar was
surprised and went there but asked from Wais that
you are not close to Prophet and you are not a
Suhabee (the people close to Prophet who are quoting
directly from Prophet words) so how it comes that
Prophet ask me to seek pray from you, and Wais
replied: I am not close to prophet and I have never
met him but once when I wanted to go and meet him I
refused going there as I had to serve my Mother.
Also we know that
there is an Islamic rule that in marriage time the
groom has to
a sum of money to
the bride as a property for her which called
“Qentar” in Arabic, this issue is an Islamic custom
which turn to be an important Islamic rule today, so
on the issue of right of speech in the public for
women, it is told that:
Once Omar the second
Islamic leader after prophet Mohammad, was talking
about Qentaar in Madena city and advising that women
should take less money and property for Nekah
(marriage), a women stood up and said: In Islam we
have right to Qentaar (lots of property to receive
for Nekah from groom) how do you dare to say that we
should get less. And Omar told yes I am mistaken and
you are right.
This story shows
that although Omar had a very high position and the
women was only an ordinary women but still as Islam
gives equal rights to men and women of all types so
Omar confessed that she was right and he was wrong.
Looking to the above
mentioned examples we can clearly say that Islam in
its fundamental rule and principles is not contrary
to the equal rights of women with men and is against
all kind of violations towards women, also the
precise instruction of Islam as in Holy Quran in
Sorat Alnessa, verse 19 and Sorat AlBaqara, verse
23 concerning the prohibition of all kinds of
hardship towards women clearly states that Islam is
against the traditions which violate women’s rights
and the traditions applied on women does not have
any root in Islam and is in contrary to Islamic
guidance.
But unfortunately
every day we are witness of applying hard
traditional practices on women which is not less
than the “live burial” in early Arab time (before
Islam).
Based on the
statements and information made available to the
participants of the conference in the first day, the
participants pointed out some of the practices
example of conflict between what Islam has guided
Muslims and how these gaudiness are against
traditional practices applied on women; as below is
some examples.
Maher:
As the justification
for getting (Maher) from an Islamic point of view
has been described above; but the way this issue is
applied in societies is very much different form its
original logic, based on which the bride family
received a huge amount from the groom family, the
bride herself will never receive the amount. So
asking for such amount and receiving such amount is
totally unlawful based on Islam, unless the girl
(bride) agrees to take the amount or unless she
wants to give the amount to her family or anybody
else.
Badal:
Also it is a
traditional practice and also it is very much common
that in order to reduce the cost of marriage, the
two families exchange the girls between each other,
this way they want to get rid off paying “Maher”.
Based on practical examples the impact of such
practices is very awful to both families, which will
be described later on. Also it is worth mentioning
that marrying the two girls at the same time from
two families is not prohibited in Islam but the
conditions that each marriage should count as a
separate process and they should not be linked to
each other by any means and they should have
separate Mahers and separate marriage formalities.
Bad:
The practical way of
applying this tradition is that to settle disputes
among two families which caused from fighting,
killing, payable dets…. A girl from the accused
family is given to the victim family based on a
decision made by both families, local council,
influential individuals…. To do such action there is
no any source in Islam as in Islam for each crime
there is a punishment set in advance and nobody
could be punished for the crimes that others
committed.
As a matter of fact,
the few above mentioned issues are only the examples
of the traditional practices applied on women which
are contrary to Islamic values and in fact all the
traditional practices and every other action which
is violating women rights are against Islamic rules
and Muslims have been instructed to avoid such
actions. In the coming pages we will review more of
such practices with more details.
Consequently,
although it has been more than 1500 years that Islam
have been introduced to the world and over these
period of time many changes have appeared in the
world but none of these changes are out of the
forecast of Quran. So, if we act up on the guidance
of Quran there will be no tradition and no act which
could violate women rights.
2. Human Rights and Traditions:
The Human rights is
the set of the norms and principles which bind all
nations of the world morally and ask them to respect
certain rules and principles. In different periods
of time the nations of the world tried to bring
peace and justice to the world in many different
ways, the Universal declaration of Human rights
adopted in the year 1948 was one of the examples of
such efforts, binding all nations equally with its
norms. The declaration itself could not guarantee
the human rights with all means, so in order to
bring more strength to the human rights application
and to strengthen the commitment and accountability
of the nations to human rights principles every year
many other conventions and protocols are introduced
and countries are encouraged to respect it and to
bind themselves to that, through which the countries
are encouraged to fortify their local and national
laws according to the mentioned principles.
Meanwhile these conventions and protocols ask the
countries to report on their performance to the
United Nation in regular terms and periods. In
addition to the general guidelines and documents in
regard of strengthening human rights, with reference
to the need of vulnerable groups like children,
IDPs, Refugees, women…. Special procedures and
arrangements are made by UN as well, this way the
efforts are made to bring more justice and guarantee
the equal right of every body.
Meanwhile, the high
commissionaire for human rights in many different
topics and issues which have a link to issues
related to the human right for a particular category
or in a particular place appoints its special
representatives to report on the situation and to
reinforce the effort to increase the respect for
human rights. This way the UN tries to avoid
violation to any category of the human beings and
also if a place or a particular group of people in
the world are suffering from a problem or an
injustice the UN tries to put the efforts together
and encourages other countries to step in and help
to overcome the problem. If we think of such actions
taken world wide we can clearly see that none of
them are obligatory rules but traditions which link
the countries morally and have been practiced for a
long period of time. The same principle and
tradition could be applied within a country as well,
as in Afghanistan we also have lots of such
practices which turn to be common and in fact they
are very much positive. As an example we can name
Loya Jirga (grant council), respecting and helping
each other in a neighborhood … which is not contrary
to the human rights principles.
Meanwhile, although
Afghanistan is a member of the UN and also is party
to many of the declarations, protocols and
conventions, which obligate the countries to respect
and apply certain human rights principles, but still
we are facing many problems and injustice towards
practicing human rights and mainly most of the
traditional practices applied on women and children
are in contrary with Human rights principles.
As mentioned above,
in Afghanistan women are considered as one of the
vulnerable groups which needs special attention and
this is way many of the traditional practices
identified as opposite to Human Rights are in
relation to Women and it affects their life very
adversely.
During the
discussions in the conference the participants named
a number of traditional practices which violates the
right of women, and as the practices become so wide
and usual even the women themselves believe in the
normality of such practices in their life.
Bellow you will read
the examples of traditional practices which are
clearly contradicted with human rights of women:
As when a baby girl
is born in a family most of the time they feel sorry
and get upset and meanwhile if it is a baby boy his
birth is hugely celebrated.
The discrimination
among boys and girls are not limited to that but it
starts from this stage and it continues over her
life time and covers all aspects of her life from
education, to social relations, marriage, economy,
etc.
Access to Education:
Based on different
studies the rate of illiteracy is very high among
Afghan people and when it comes to women it is even
worse and one of the main reasons being is the
discrimination pointed out above. Based on such
discriminations, the families are less willing to
send their daughters to school, and even if they
want to send them, they have limited resources and
opportunities. They prefer to send sons than
daughters, which is strongly contradicted to the
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) article
2nd.
Forced marriages:
The CRC defines any
person bellow 18th as a child, and considers them as
immature. This fact affects all affairs of the life
of human being including marriage, but the
traditional thinking and the mentality of the people
in many of the incidents lead to the marriage of
people under 18th and even as young as 10 to 7 years
old, applied predominantly on girls. More over, when
it comes to marriage women and girls do not have the
right to express their views or involved in the
decisions and they should obey the decisions taken
by family especially male member of the family.
Words, phrases and
proverbs used for women:
Using names and
words are very important when it comes to the mental
and moral growth of the people from the childhood,
as we know it is very common that women and girls
are named and called with many different words in
the families which become very natural; which from a
psychological point of view disturb them mentally
and affect their growth:
Neek Sar:
when a baby boy is born after a girl this girl
called Neek Sar (Good person)
Bad Sar:
If a baby girl born after a girl the first girl
called Bad Sar (Bad person)
Sia Sar:
girls from their birth till death called Sia Sar
(black headed)
Aajeza:
women are also called Aajeza (as disabled and bad
luck person)
Calling women from
very early ages with the above mentioned names and
many more of these types affect them
psychologically. From the very early age they
believe that their birth and their existence is a
matter to be sorry for, so they grow with a guilty
feeling from the beginning and this feeling
transfers from one generation to the next and slowly
it becomes a natural reality of their life.
Also some of the
examples of the proverbs in this regard were
mentioned by the participants of the conference:
- You should kill
the cat when she steps in (women should be under
control and pressure from the first day of the
marriage)
- don’t consult with
the women as they are not mature mentally
- hide your
important issues from your wife
- Women is Obey
- Zan Bezan, Agar
Murd Degar Zan Agar Namurd Degar Zan, (women should
be beaten, if she dies get second wife if she
doesn’t, beat her again.)
Mentality exists
regarding women position in the Family:
Based on the
traditional believes among the families women in the
family circle is considered as secondary human
being, in most of such families men are in the high
rocky of the family tree and he is the one who can
decide about every thing and his word is final word.
The women have the second role after all men in the
family. The wife should consult and ask for
permission from her husband and in the absence of
the husband from his brother in law, father in law …
in different ways if she wants to do any thing,
regardless of their age ( if she is not married she
has take permission from her father, brother…)
As one of the
participants of the conference explains an example
about it:
As I was working for
a health education program we needed to hire some
female health educators, so I went to one of the
families which I knew there are women who can work
with us and as her husband was not in town she said
although her husbands would have been agreed if he
was there but because he is not there she has to ask
from her brother in law and when she asked , he
refused so we needed to wait for her husband or
should convince the brother in law, and it took
plenty of time for me to convince him and only then
she was able to work with us.
3. Legislation and
traditions:
In the legal system
of our country the traditions are accepted as the
main source for the legislation, but when we talk
about the traditions as the source of legislation,
we talk about the set of traditions which are in
conformity with Islam and human rights declarations
and the traditions which are not against mentioned
principles. Also the cause for having legislation
and written law as mentioned in its historical
background is mainly to avoid any irresponsible
actions by the people in power and to make every
body accountable before law and principles and the
important element of any law in the world (including
Afghanistan) and it should not be in contrary with
religious and human rights values.
But what is
important and this report tries to emphasis is the
circle for the implementation of laws and rules,
unfortunately the executive aspect of the rules and
regulation have been very weak over the years of war
and even before and after war period (till now).
Main reasons for the lack of applications of the
laws in the country’s present life is the lack of
professionals and law enforcement mechanisms and
structures all over the country, high rate of
illiteracy among people, the main factors for
turning of people in many parts of the country to
practice traditional norms and rules. Since these
traditional norms are not written any where and the
main source for generating such rules are not clear
so it applies from the people of power to the rest
of the people who are mainly vulnerable.
At the same time, if
we pay attention to this issue from a different
angle we also can say that the written laws of our
country, because of the years of war and the brain
drain of the people is not responsive to the needs
of the today’s life of the country and in many parts
it needs to be rewritten and reformed, as for many
of the current violence in the today’s society are
not very well addressed by law or its reference is
very weak which can not ensure the equal right of
every body.
More over because
women have less presence in the public and their
access to education and social life is limited they
are not aware of the rights given to them by laws,
and that is why they are the main victims of the
violence caused by traditional practices, and
because they don’t have access to the law
enforcement mechanisms no body tries to ensure
justice for them.
Fro among the
practice applied on women which is in contrary with
Legislation enforced in the country, we can name
forced marriages, early marriages, physical abuse...
which is very common. So there is a strong need for
reviewing the existing legislation of the country in
order to bring appropriate and positive changes
about, which can bind every body with its rules and
regulations.
To make it short,
the other main problem occurred when we are talking
of Legislation and tradition is creating and
improving the sense of escaping from the laws by the
people and when people get used to traditional
practices then it becomes more difficult to apply
rules and also we should take this issue in to
consideration that only by changing rules and
improving legislation we will not be able to reduce
the violations to the women rights; we need to bring
more awareness and moral strength to community and
increase the sense of respect to rule of law among
people.
4. Governance and
Traditions:
Since the fall of
Taliban, the Afghan Government always mentioned the
issue of war lords, local commanders, drugs and many
other issues as main problem towards peace and
justice for Afghanistan but failed to mention the
tradition practices as one of the main challenges
towards development and women rights, which is even
greater and more serious than many other problems.
Because the existence of practices mentioned above
can create social unbalance and can lead to social
disasters in the country, can create obstacles
towards enjoying the normal and natural rights to
different groups of the community.
When we want to move
towards peace and justice the issue of traditional
practices can be seen as one of the main problems
and obstacles in this regard, which we need to
struggle against it even before any other issues. As
above we mentioned the issue of legislation and
traditional practices and pointed out the problems
in regard to that now we should mention that the
reason for the lack of application of the
legislation is the weak performance of government
structure. The law enforcement structures like
police, public prosecutors and other related
departments play a key role for implementation of
rule of law.
Meanwhile we should
mention that the strong believe and linkage of
people to local norms and their own made structures
could be seen as a treat to Government, because by
the time these structures get strong people in such
places are unlikely to see themselves part of the
country and it is unlikely that they would obey
national rules in a longer perspective, as in a
traditional and tribal community all faiths are
based on language and tribal divisions and
interests, for examples in Afghanistan today if some
one is in the position of power they tries to place
as many people of their groups and tribes as
possible.
In the same way when
a traditional practice violates the rights of women
it creates many different applications and it shows
that the government have been failed to fulfill one
of its important duty of “protecting the rights of
the citizens”.
So bringing the
judicial reform itself will not be enough to resolve
the problems created by traditional practices, to do
so, government needs to adopt different long term
and short term policies for raising the awareness
among people (on the contradiction of such practices
with Islam, Human rights and rule of law),
strengthening the mechanisms of law enforcement
country wide, building the capacity of judicial
sector and many more.
As movements from
darkness to brightness needs to be slow down and
otherwise it could create problems for your eyes in
the same way our movements for such struggle also
needs to be slow and step by step and according to
the understanding and capacity present in the
community.
5. Justice and
Traditions:
The judicial sector
is one of the strong elements of a governmental
structure in each country including Afghanistan, but
in Muslim countries Islam has also given special
power to this structure, this is why the
constitution of Afghanistan also recognized it as
the special power of this structure.
In fact the only way
to apply rule of law and ensure justice in a country
is to have a strong, independent and professional
judiciary, as they are responsible to ensure social
justice in the country ( this issue is more evident
in the swearing statement of each judge while
taking over a judiciary post). In short the
constitution gives a very strong responsibility to
the judiciary of the country, which is in need of
having appropriate and strong structure and
facilities as well.
As was explained
above the main problem towards applying rule of law
and ensure justice is the existence of traditional
practices and traditional structures which act as
informal justice system in the country, and as the
formal judicial structures and personnel do not
exist every where in the country, so these
structures become more strong day to day. In
addition, while people don’t have any other means to
solve their problem in their area so they refer to
informal justice system as a result of which the
level of trust to formal justice is reduced
gradually.
Bellow we want to
refer to the issues within the judiciary which lead
to the strengthening of the informal justice and it
need a special attention:
1. It has been
noticed that the judiciary personnel in some parts
of the country are the head of the local councils as
well , under the current mentality of the public
they are also the applicators of traditional norms,
2. The lack of the
judiciary structure and courts all over the country
also contribute to the fact that the informal
justice becomes stronger and replace the judiciary
and lack of transportation means make people to
refer to informal structure,
3. Low level of
public awareness from the laws and procedures in
provinces, districts and villages also have a strong
contribution to the wide practice of informal
justice and when it comes to women this issue
becomes stronger than usual.
4. In the case of
women another contributing factor is the limited
access to public life. It is unlikely even if they
know their rights to ask for justice or refer to any
judiciary structure,
As a result, we
should keep in mind that considering the above
mentioned issues lightly or not paying attention to
such an important and crucial issue will cause to
strengthening of the informal justice system which
will damage the justice value in total.
Second Section
Traditional
practices in Afghanistan and its impact to the Women
Rights
Our traditional
society is overvalued by traditional practices,
which mainly affect women life and most of the time
violate their rights. In this part of the report is
the summary of the discussions during the conference
regarding identifying traditional practices,
analyzing its direct impacts, seeking solutions and
also identifying structures and organization which
can contribute to reforming the situation in this
regards:
Most Common
Traditional practices applied on women:
As was mentioned
before, although we have number of positive
traditional norms but here we would like to name the
practices which violates the rights of women in
different parts of the country and will also try to
analyze some of these practices:
A. List of
traditional practices regarding women:
1. Bad
2. Forced Marriages
3. Toyana (Bride
Price)
4. Multi marriages
(against Islamic instructions)
5. Exchange of
brides between families
6. Early marriages
(age difference)
7. Giving women in
compensation of debts.
8. Forced marriage
of widows to the relatives of husband
9. Avoid paying the
heritage shared with women
10. Engage baby
girls when they are born to be married to some body
later in the life,
11. Discrimination
against women
12. Not permitting
girls to access to education
13. Exchange of
women with animals
14. Exchange of
women with drugs
15. Absence of women
in the decision making process in the family
16. Avoid women
access to social work and employment
17. Avoid presence
of women in the local councils
18. Lack of
economical independence of women
19. Feeling ashamed
for the birth of girls and feeling proud for the
birth of boys
b. Analyzing the
most common traditional practices on women:
Although all
participants of the conference were agreed that
there are more damaging traditional practices
existing against women, they emphasized on a number
of most common practices, bellow you will find a
brief description of each discussed tradition:
1. Childhood
Engagements (early marriage):
One of the most
common practices in Afghanistan is the early
engagement of the children, the way these traditions
are applied might be different in various parts of
the country, but it has equal implication. This
tradition is mainly applied by families of boy and
girl, and mostly the main cause is the poverty (of
the girl’s family) and power (of the boy’s family)
but sometimes it also happened among families who
are relatives to each other or friends and they are
happy to build a new relationship. The implication
of this tradition is negative in most of the times
and when both sides are mature this family decision
turn to forced marriage.
The way this
tradition is applied is; when a new baby girl is
born in a family, some time the family who have a
baby boy comes and for the baby girl (in some part
of the country the mother of the boy came and sweep
the door step of the girl house and it means that
they ask for the girl) and in some other time the
issue of power is involved and the boy family which
is mostly older than normal; shot from a gun and by
this means announce that this new baby girl belongs
to his family from now on so nobody including the
girl’s family cannot dare to refuse.
2. Forced Marriages:
This issue is also
very much common in different parts of the country,
even among the very civilized families it looks like
a very natural issue. Although forced marriages are
mainly applied on women but in some cases men are
also the victim of forced marriages. Some times
families are the main actor in applying forced
marriages but as was mentioned before mainly the
position of power whether economical, political,
military or social influences could be counted as
the main causes for such actions.
Based on the Islamic
norms, consent to marriage is the crucial elements
of marriage, without which the legality of the
marriage is under question, but as the Islamic
knowledge has been weak among the public, most of
the time to marriages are arranged by putting
pressure to the women and is totally based on
tradition, which has very damaging application to
the life of the young couple. It really happened
that the forced marriage is successful, because in
the forced marriage both sides can not make their
own decisions, their choice and thinking is not
involved in the decision, which cause lack of
interest to the marriage life, psychological
problems, wrong impact on children, and even in the
worst cases it ends up with suicides and mental
illness.
So raising awareness
of the public and families to the side effect of
such actions through religious leaders, teachers,
and other well known people in the public is very
much crucial, meanwhile government should encourage
marriage registration and formal marriages so it can
reduce the problem in this regard.
3. Considering
widows as property of husband family:
In most parts of the
country it is quite common that the widows are
considered as the property of the husband family. By
the time the husband dies immediately the wife loses
all her power and rights, and she is not anymore
considered as an independent person. In most of the
cases the way of her life is chosen by the in-laws,
even the in-laws are able to remarry her to one of
their sons or any body at all in their family
regardless of her agreement, age difference,
positions, etc. If she refuses, then she has to pay
a very high price for that and it means they will
take away her children and make her to leave the
family immediately.
The decision in this
regard is mostly taken by the in-laws, and the women
could not interfere at all.
The impact of such
marriage is obvious as it was in forced marriages
(this sentence to be inserted in Dari version as
well)
To overcome such
practices again there is a strong need for awareness
raising among public, building the self esteem of
women, helping them to become economically
empowered, advices from religious leaders… could
bring a positive change to the situation. Meanwhile
strengthening the rule of law, easy access of women
to justice are the most important elements of
ensuring women safety in this regard.
4. Exchanging women:
The main cause for
such tradition which is very much common as well is
the poverty and the families for reducing the heavy
cost of marriage ceremonies, agrees to exchange
their daughters and reduce the cost and arrange both
marriages at the same time.
If you look at the
issue at first you won’t find any problem with that
and you might think what is wrong with that, but a
deep analyses and looking to the situation of
couples who married in the above mentioned condition
make it clear that it has damaging impact to the
life of them. (to be inserted in Dari version as
well) as the life of these couples are joined now
for ever with each other and every and each up and
down of the life of one couple effect the other as
well.
As we read in the
following example:
In a family the two
couples were married in the above mentioned way and
in one of the families the situation gone worse and
the problems between husband and wife lead them to
divorce, but the second couple didn’t have any
problem. By the time the divorced women came back to
her father house her brother (2nd couple) divorced
her wife too, so in this way both families got in to
trouble.
The above mentioned
example clearly shows the damaging effect of such
practices in the families.
5. Avoid payment of
heritage to women:
Access to the
heritage is one the rights which have been given to
Muslims mainly by Islamic rules, but in practice
this rights has been denied to women in most of the
cases and their claim to receive their heritage will
face to aggressive behavior from the brother, father
and even mother and it creates many problems in
their family relations. This is why some time women
them selves refuse to receive their share to avoid
conflict in the family but most of the time if the
claim still they will not receive any thing.
The main cause here
is the strong decision making position of men in the
family and also the mentality that women don’t need
wealth, because they are the responsibility of men
(father, brother, husband, son…).
But we should think
of the women who are divorced or simply don’t have
any male accompany but still they need to survive,
there are women who lost every body and they haven’t
had any chance to work and gain income, but they
need to survive and there are women that the share
of heritage could save their life with their
children life. Still these traditions denying this
right from women, which could be one the reasons for
women’s weak economical power. The consequences
brought up by such tradition is facing women with
economical problem, which lead them to forced
marriages, suicides, self immolations, moral crimes
and so on.
6. Bad:
This tradition have
been applied mainly by local councils and
traditional informal justice systems, which involves
religious leaders, economically powered people,
influential people, local commanders, etc in the
decisions.
The traditions
applied in a way that to reduce the conflict among
families which caused by killing, robbery, loan,
running away, rape… a women from the abuser family
is given to victim family as exchange of the damage.
Basically the justification is that such tradition
will reduce the conflict and by creating family
relationship the abuse will be forgotten, but in
reality and based on in depth researches have been
done and the practical examples given by
participants this action will never put an end to
the tension between two families but will increase
it and more over another innocent person (the women)
has to sacrifice for the crime that others have
committed.
6. Multiple
marriages:
Although Islam has
granted the right for more than one marriage to men,
but meanwhile has made it conditional to very
difficult and almost impossible prerequisites, and
the reason being is that except for unusual
situations nobody can just marry for several times
just for fun or for sexual purpose. But
unfortunately what has been practiced in Afghanistan
today in regards of polygamy (multiple marriages) is
not based on Islam and it is only based on
traditions. Who can imagine that the number of the
multiple marriages in Afghanistan is even more than
any other country in the world, and maybe out of
each 10 women in Afghanistan one have been faced or
have the fear of facing such thing in her marriage
life.
But what men
justifies mainly when they are marrying for more
than one time is not having sons, and because they
think that sons will help them when they are old
they make such decisions but most of the time even
in the 2nd, 3rd … marriages they failed to have
sons. Nevertheless, according to the participants,
the main reason behind these polygamies is nothing
but their whishes, desires and wealth which makes
them to marry several times, which never could be
justified based on Islam and the rule of law.
What is more painful
is that most of the time it is women (mother,
sister…) are perusing the men to marry for the
second time, meanwhile as mentioned, the civil law
has pointed out some guidance and instructions as of
article 84 but the law enforcement mechanism has
never taken this issue seriously. It launches
conditions but never says that if such thing
happened against law what the punishment would be.
Meanwhile because
this tradition has become so wide spread slowly it
turn to be a very naturally to have more than one
wife, while the impact and the consequences brought
up by this tradition will never be a natural thing
and it is very much damaging, from such damaging
impacts we can name the conflict over heritage,
discrimination among children, and wives, etc.
One of the main
cause for the women to obey the action of her
husband for second time marriage is because they are
economically dependent to their husbands and in case
of resistance they have no option, no place to
leave; and she has to accept it as her destiny.
Meanwhile she has
the fear that if she wants to live separately from
her husband or ask for divorce so then based on law
she will not be able to have her children.
In the opinion of
the participants of the conference the main solution
to overcome such problem is to reinforce the rule of
law, and strongly implement it; because if the law
is applied on women for not receiving their children
but the same law which provides conditions for the
second marriage of men are never applied, so if we
want to resolve such problems we ought to improve
our judiciary system.
7. Exchange of women with animals, drugs,
debts…:
This tradition is
one of the most unfortunate practices in our
country, but it is mainly brought up by years of
war, and when you want to categorize it, we can put
it as a variety of BAD practice (which was mentioned
above) but as this tradition is more disturbing the
participants emphasized to address it separately as
well.
Based on this
tradition for different unjustifiable reasons and
based on the decisions made by local councils and
some times families, it applies again on women and
the exchange to receive animals, drugs, pay debts,
receive lands, etc, which without any doubt is less
worthy than the life of a human being.
The underlying
factor for such an unfortunate action is ignorance,
men’s weak conscience, poverty… which have brought
many different examples.
Please read bellow
some examples about this mal-practice:
A men was arranging
the marriage ceremony for his son and based on
traditions when the bride has stepped in to her
husband family the in-laws should kill an animal
like; chicken, goat, sheep, cow to welcome her; and
as this men didn’t have money to arrange for it; he
gives one of his daughters to a land lord in the
village to receive a cow.
Also in another
example:
A men had the Buz
Kashi hobby (a traditional game in Afghanistan which
plays by horse and also a dead goat) and during a
match his horse was sick and he was about to miss
the match; so he gives one of his daughters to
exchange it with a horse.
8. Not permitting
girls to access to education
One of the main
problems in our society is the lack of access of
women and girls to education, which is the cause for
most of other social problem and is applied based on
the family decisions and sometimes other reasons
like; security, limited facilities, etc.
The decision to
avoid the access of education for girls is totally
against Islam and mainly the first guidance brought
up to prophet Muhammad (PBUH) which was saying (Eqraa….)
it means read, in an imperative accent.
Although today
people and families slowly come to understand and
realize the importance of education in their life
but still in most parts of the country if a girl is
going to school even in a very primary level
considers a big shame for the honor of the family.
And even if a girl is lucky enough to get the chance
to go to school by the time somebody asks the family
to marry their daughter, she is immediately taken
out of school; and the next day poor girl instead of
going to school has to go to the husband family and
survive there for all of her life.
The damaging impact
of such action has caused the isolation of women
from the society and most of the time they commit
suicide, self burning, running away from the house
and many other actions.
10. Expensive
Marriages:

Marriage as the
beginning of a new life, is one of the important
events of ones life in our country and based on
traditions, people want to celebrate it as luxurious as
possible, which is considered as fun time but at the
same time the illogical, unaffordable cost of the
marriages could provide some joy for some families
but for most of the families it is
very much damaging and even it Causes immediate
divorces and difficult living conditions for a great
part of the young couples. As for having a very
luxurious wedding party, they have to arrange for
big amount of money and some times if they don’t
have such amount, they have to take loan from others
which then after marriage they need to spend all the
time and energy to pay the loans.
Although some times
arranging for luxurious weddings are voluntary but
most of the time it is compulsory and by force which
then will have many negative implications. If the
bride family forces the groom family to pay high
price for the marriage (in Afghanistan wedding
ceremony organized by groom family) then after
marriage the position and the personality of the new
bride is not very good in her in-laws family and
also it provokes violence, fighting … among the
family.
Also if we want to
look at this issue from another angle, we might
realize that this traditions obligate young men who
do not have enough wealth to arrange for such
expensive weddings and pay the high marriage cost,
they remain single for longtime and meanwhile
because this is the families who applies such
traditions many of the young girls also will never
have the chance to marry the person of their choice.
Creation of such difficult conditions for the young
people who want to get married and start their new
life some times lead to elopes, moral crimes,
psychological problem…
11. Physical abuses:
Applying physical
abuses on women and girls are one the very common
practice in almost every family, as men have more
physical power; they are willing to use their power
against the women if women do not obey their orders.
This action does not only cause physical suffering
and disturbance but also creates many more damaging
impacts, psychological problems, committing crimes
against the abusers, suicides, moral crimes, etc
from the women part.
C. Decision making
structures and their operation mechanism:
As was mentioned
before, the traditional practices could be applied
by different structures and even individuals. These
traditional structures might differ from each other
on their historical age and also the way of
operation but all the decisions taken by all these
structures are compulsory and the villagers, the
family members or any body else who is living under
one of these structures are obliged to obey;
otherwise sets of punishments are set out by the
structure like separation from the family, taking
him/ her out of the family or structure and
sometimes more hard reaction.
Bellow we will
review some of such structures which was mentioned
by the participants of the conference as the main
structures:
I. Jirgas:
One of the well
known traditional structures for decision making is
the Jirga, which is popular for settlement of
disputes all over country and is consisted of local
influential community members.
A. the
structure: the members of the Jirga is
mainly elderly people ( also referred as
white-bearded men) which are called Mesher. All
members of the Jirga have equal rights in decision
making and now we name each of these members:
-
White-bearded:
respecting the elder people (white-bearded) is the
responsibility of all members of the society (
people get punished if they don’t respect their
elders ) and normally they are known for their
experience a fruit of their life.
-
Khan (land lord):
he is a member of Jirga without question because he
has wealth and pays the cost of many different
religious and local events and is respected by the
community and has special power. Khan is the member
of the Jirga but sometimes he is the one who calls
for convening the meeting, he also manages the
village.
-
Religious leaders
(white-turbaned):
they are also very much respected in the community
and are playing a crucial role in reducing and
solving conflict as they are well known for their
Islamic knowledge. Historically during wars these
are the people who put white turbans and by getting
the oat of both side of depute on Holy book of
Muslims (Quran) they could settle a dispute.
-
Village leader
(Sar Khail): this position is common in tribal life
and each tribe has a leader and they are mainly
KOCHIS (nomads).
-
Malik:
also is a position of power in the villages and is
the member of the Jirga.
B.
Method of operation:
the procedure of operation is that the members of
the Jirga come together in a open space or most of
the time in the mosque and after discussing the
issues make their decisions. Nobody can refuse the
decisions and it is compulsory; they disobedient
receive punishment which will be applied by a group
called (monitoring group). The Monitoring group is
consisted of 10 young people and they are also
called “Arbaki” in some places and they have a
leader which they chosen from them by themselves.
This group act as law enforcement staff and
following up of the decisions taken by Jirga is
their responsibility.
II. Maraka:
Maraka
is a different type of the local structure and its
difference with Jirga is that it is mainly held for
minor issues and it has limited members.
A. Structure:
following you
can find the potential members in each Marak:
a.
Marakchi (the members of the Maraka): these are the
group who do the hearing of the cases.
b.
Nekhyan (knowledgeable people): it calls to the
people who have enough knowledge to solve problems,
they are also member of the Maraka and they make
decisions based on the rules and principles of the
village (the principles are called Nerkh) the Nerkhi
is not nessocery to be wealthy but is important to
know the rules and principles of the village.
B. Procedure:
the same as the Jirga. Obeying the decisions of this
structure is also compulsory to the both parties.
III. The Families:
Families are also
the main implementers of the traditional practices
in the family circle but they don’t have structure
and procedures like Maraka and Jirga. But in the
following issues families are the only implementers
of the practices on women:
|
Implementers in the Family |
Type of
tradition |
No |
|
Father, Grant father, Mother, grand
mother, brother, uncles... |
Forced marriages |
1 |
|
Father, Mother |
Denied access to education |
2 |
|
Husband and in-laws |
Multiple marriages |
3 |
|
Brother, uncle, elder of the family and
some time mother |
Denied from heritages |
4 |
|
Mother, father, grand mother and father,
uncles |
Early marriages |
5 |
|
Bride family |
Expensive wedding costs |
6 |
|
Families of bride and groom |
Exchange of women by women |
7 |
|
Father, brother, husbands.. |
Exchange for animals, drugs.. |
8 |
D. Proposed
solutions:
Based on the
three-day discussion among the participants of the
conference the participants emphasized on the
following issues as the main solutions to solve the
problem in regards of traditional practices
As the main reason
for applying the mentioned practices was identified
the ignorance among community, so raising the public
awareness and providing civic education to public
including men and women is very much crucial which
should be applied together from the government,
civil society groups, religious leader..
Expanding and
strengthening the rule of law is another important
element for elimination of such harsh practices from
afghan women’s lives.
Meanwhile actions
like improving security, equal access to education,
providing chances to increase income generation
opportunity for the families and mainly for women
could contribute strongly as solutions. (Detailed
proposals for solution is highlighted in the
conference declaration as annex 2)
Annexes
1. Speeches:
1.2. Dr. Suraya
Subhrang Duputy Minister of MoWA
Topic: Struggle on
violence against women:
With greetings to
every body and thanks from WCLRF for Organizing such
conference; It is too difficult
to speak in a among very knowledgeable personalities
but as the issue is important I want to raise some
points: Seeing that every body knows we are living
in a society, where traditions as
unwritten
laws
are stronger than rule of law applied by government
of Afghanistan. I think we should review analyses of
the practices to see what the good and bad practices
are in this regard. It is a
reality that we have a
number of practices which are part of our honor and
are cultural heritage of our country and each of us
has the responsibility to make and keep these
traditions alive and transfer it to the next
generations. These traditions are like tolerance,
helping each other, consultation…but besides that
unfortunately we have a number of bad practices as
well which applies mainly on women and these are the
main obstacles when we are trying to analyze the
situation of women in afghan
society.
Regarding the
position of the men and women in the society we can
bring the old example of the two wings of a bird, as
women and men considered like the two wings of one
bird, which with out one of these wings the bird can
not fly; the same is the movement of the society. In
our society one wing of the bird have been tied up
for a long period of time and although now there are
a number of opportunities still this wing of the
society can not fly properly; why???
One of the main
causes is the customary law in Afghanistan, which
creates an environment of conflict and violence for
women and in such situation these are men who rule
the family and the society and the women are to obey
such rules. So one of the main points for tiding up
of one wing of the society is traditional practices;
as one of the knowledgeable persons says: (the
situation of women in a society is like the mirror
which reflects the level of civilization in a
society) from this mirror you can judge and measure
that how much this society is advanced, so if in a
society half of its population are ignored and their
role has been denied in the political, economical
and social affairs; such a society will not meet the
criteria of a civilized country or society.
If we consider
traditional practices as one of the main causes of
violence towards women, we clearly see that such
traditions originates from the grassroots (from the
birth of the child) when a baby girl is born in a
family the reaction of the family towards the event
is different than if it was a baby boy; and for the
girl every body gets upset and feel sorry for not
being a baby boy. It means the traditional
discrimination against women starts from her birth
and then it gets further in the issue of going to
school, as the preference is that boys should go to
school if the facilities are limited or simply
because girls don’t have the permission in most of
the family to go to school. So this is the cause
that now we have majority of our country (75%)
illiterate and among them rate of illiteracy of
women raises up to the 92%.
So if we claim that
women should have equal presence and participation
in social, political and economical life it starts
from equal opportunities in getting education and
skills, while majority of women in our society have
been denied to access their right to education and
this action in itself is a kind of violation, which
has a root in our traditional practices.
In the same ways
when the age of a girl child is raised up to the 10
or 12, immediately she should be married, and it is
clear that in such an age she is not mature enough
to take over the responsibility of married women and
can manage the family. The tradition of early
marriage beside its damaging impact on the family
life also causes that the majority of women remain
illiterate.
Also when we look at
to the issue of health, if a woman is ill and she is
not carried to hospital until her conditions gets
worse and she is close to death, which also has a
root in the traditional thinking of people, which
thinks that taking women to a doctor, as she needs
to get permission from her husband or if the husband
is not there from her brother in law, father in law
or any other male member of the family to go to
doctor and if they say no so she can not go. (The
doctors in villages are mainly men, as women have
limit opportunity to become doctor and then work in
remote area and villages). If we pay attention we
can see that in every half an hour a pregnant women
dies, which it self is a catastrophe and it is main
root is in the traditions.
Meanwhile in the
issue of economy, most of the women in our country
are economically dependent to male member of the
families, as they are mainly illiterate, and also
based on traditions they are not allowed to have
public presence, or learn skills or work anywhere.
And their economical dependency causes that they
have no any role in the decisions making at the
family level and if the women are not economically
strong they will never be able to claim their equal
rights with the men, because if a women works it
helps her a lot to maintain and strengthen her
personality. So I think with finding solutions for
such traditional practices we will be able to move
forwards and ensure women rights.
And to overcome the
traditional practices in our society, the society
needs to bind with rule of law and through
strengthening the rule of law we will be able to
ensure justice and equality for women and stop
violence.
We heard that, a
husband some time ago cut the nose and ears of her
wife and then put boiled oil on her, because she
kissed her son in law. Do you think such an action
could be justified by the name of culture;
absolutely no, these are the hard traditions brought
up by years of war to our country, and doers of such
actions are mentally sick, as based on an assessment
70% of our society is mentally disturbed. Also what
do you think of the incident in the Kabul
University; when one student killed another student
in the public, do you think he was normal, no, he
was not. We should mention that most of the
incidents we have witnessed in our country has
nothing to do with our culture and it is only the
culture of war and violence which slowly take over
in the traditional practices, as unfortunately today
we are facing cultural poverty, we have to fight
against it for a long time, until we will be able to
find the honor and privilege we had before.
We come back to the
point of the need of improving the rule of law, as
today we have the new constitution which, guarantee
most of the rights for women and also as reference
to prohibition of traditional practices.
President Karzai in
one of his speeches in the event of birthday of
Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) referred to the traditional
practices like, BAD, Exchange of women, early
marriages as the practices against Islam and asked
the religious leaders to fight against it and asked
them to raise the awareness of people about these
issues which are against Islam as there is no
reference in Quran on that and also no where in
Quran the women asked to stay at home and not take
part in the social life.
But we should note
that to implement the rule of law and to ensure
implementation of legal rights; women can play an
important role and in fact their roles are much
stronger than men. It means that women should not
think or believe any more that knowing rules and
making sure that these rules are implemented is only
the job of men, the women should know and understand
what is law and how it can help them changing their
life. They should know what are the rights which
have been guaranteed for them in the constitution,
what is their civil rights… and when they understand
all the above mentioned issues only then they will
be able to seek justice and bring changes to their
lives, then she will not feel as a week and feared
person and then she will realize that laws have been
given her particular rights.
Also it is important
to raise the awareness among men on the issues
related to gender, that is why we in the MoWA are
trying to reach men as much as possible on this
issue and train them on this important issue, then
they will be able to respect each others right.
Also when we say
that the laws should be implemented, it is important
that at the first stage the way should be paved for
this purpose, if the society is not prepare to
accept changes it is impossible to bring changes; so
if the society is not ready to respect and implement
the rule of law it means that we have failed in
implementing the rule of law as well. Consequently,
when the public and the society get ready to accept
changes then it is the time that , people who are
aware and understand the issue help others to
understand it well, only then public will realize
that practices like BAD, early marriages… are wrong.
Today unfortunately we force a 10 years old girl to
marry a 50 years old man; while these two belong to
two different generations and never can suit each
other and this is why we have an increasing number
of suicide, self immolation and many other cases in
which a women tries to end her life. That is why we
believe that the impact of traditional practices
damaging people mentally.
And when a mother
(who is a women) has mental and psychological
problem, how she could bring up mature and healthy
children to the society, thus we will have a society
full of social problems.
As we said one of
the important elements for a national development
program is to bolster the cultural side of the
society, we should help our people to understand
that BAD is bad, early marriage is wrong…
Although most of the
people today don’t have the patience and tolerance
to accept that: Yes we have negative points and
always we love to hear every body saying that we are
perfect; but if we want to pave our way towards
development, we should realize our weak points and
we should change it to our strength and only then we
will be able to avoid doing mistakes again. And to
do so we need to put our steps slowly, we should not
hurry up and should be very careful.
Thus we should also
be happy that so far we have lots of achievements in
insuring women rights, our new constitution with
particular attention to women rights, the process of
judicial reform, which we are very much hopeful for
it and many other positive steps are all signs that
there are improvements.
At the end, on be
half of the MoWA, I would like to once more
appreciate the initiative of WCLRF for organizing
such an important gathering.
1.2. Mr. Farid
Hamidi, Commissioner at Afghan Independent Human
Right Commission (AIHRC)

Topic: A glance on
the traditional practices in Afghanistan
I think that the
title of the conference “the Impact of traditional
practice on Afghan Women” have been chosen very
much correctly and thoughtfully.
As by this way we
will be able to address a part of the social problems
existing in our society which re--lates to our future
social, cultural and political development and
tries to build up a social balance. Because if we
are not looking to our traditional practices and not
distinguished among right and wrong traditional
practices we will not be able to provide
opportunities for political, social and economical
development of our country.
In the past three
years the Afghan Government has always addressed the
issue of war lords, drugs… as main problems and
obstacles towards development, but I think the
problem created by traditional practices is even
bigger, as it creates societal imbalance and bring
obstacles towards development, democracy, social
justice and also it stops people to enjoy their
rights and freedom.
That is why when we
are moving towards development and carrying out the
slogans of democracy and human rights, we should
also try to bring changes towards our social
behavior. One of the issues that has always been
pointed out is that Afghanistan is moving from a
traditional society to a more developed society. The
traditional society is the society where faith and
favor are not very deep. This is one of the most
important problems in our society, because this
issue creates lack of trust among people, which has
its root in our traditional practices and believes.
So we should understand that the problem with
traditional practices is not only for women but is a
problem for our nation.
Today if a person
get an important position he/she tries to hire more
her/his relatives and friends around and he/ she
trust only the people who are close to him/her, as
we have a very old proverb that “if a relative kill
you he will pull your body from sun to shadow and if
a noncreative kills you under the sun and will never
pull your body from the heat of the sun out” this is
why people rely more to their tribes, they think
from a tribal perspective and it is the reason that
national faith and favor is never get strong
The other problem
brought up by traditional practices is the luck of
public trust to rule of law and as a result of that
escaping to implement laws; everyday we claim that
if the there is no rule of law people will not live
with peace but we never think of the reason for not
respecting rule of and the reason is strong presence
of traditional practices which slowly tries to
replace the rule of law.
So one of the main
problems towards rule of law, development, and
democracy is the traditions, which we have to
strongly fight against it.
Before the issue of
judicial reform was mentioned, but I think the
judicial reform on its own will not be able to solve
the problems created by traditional practices and
the government should establish and implement many
other long term policies to overcome traditional
practices, and in this way we will be able to move
towards democracy and rule of law and human right
and ensures the access of people to their rights.
As was said we need
to distinguish between negative and positive
traditional practices, there are a number of habits
which can lead us to peace and development and can
give us our national identity, and we have to
separate these from the shameful practices which
decrease our honor and we need to get rid of them.
As we said there are
number of good practices which now have become part
of constitution, like Loya Jirga, the value of
consultation, peace building…, which we have feel
its impact over the period of time and luckily today
it has been reflected in our constitution.
But strongly and
urgently we need to fight against the traditional
practices which are against laws, and principles of
human rights, and we have to find different
appropriate ways to overcome such traditions; and in
this way we will be able to bring balance between
democracy, rule of law and development in our
country.
Today in Afghanistan
we have so many different things and issues which
are contradictory to each other and they are all
practices at the same time; from one side we have
traditional practices which create problems for our
accountability towards Islam and rule of law and on
the other hand we have principles and terms like
Human rights, freedom, democracy…. And as all these
different and various issues are living at the same
time thus it creates an environment of conflict or
the conflict of interest for us.
In order to ensure
the political and social development of Afghanistan
and bring the issues like social justice, democracy,
people participation, human right and many more in
to practice; we have to find and plant the seed of
the issue in our society.
As I said before
Afghanistan is a traditional country and if we want
to move from such situation to a more civilized and
mature society; a society where the legality of
power, and structures are assured based on rule of
law and justifications; we need to say good bye to
traditional practices, traditional structures and
thinking because most of these elements are the
obstacles towards guaranteeing human rights in the
country.
Also another issue;
which is very much important is the traditional
practices brought up by the man-lordism mentality
and has damaging impact on the dignity of women and
children and their life. Lets look at the
traditional practice of BAD as an example; in this
tradition we see that nobody can tolerate such an
action that the crime is committed by a man and a
women as to suffer or pay the price by going to the
victim family and living their for ever; so thinking
of such practice made as more strong in our fight
against negative traditional practices. So fighting
against such actions is not only important for
defending women right but it is also crucial for
building up social justice and bringing about social
balance.
But, as her
Excellency Deputy Minister has already stated; we
need to slow down our efforts and think twice when
we want to do any thing to confront traditional
practices, and we should speed up in a way which can
break and fail our efforts instead. So replacing the
traditional structures and practices should be step
by step and before that we have to prepare the
mentality of public accordingly and these changes
should not be in way which can create different
negative feelings for the public; otherwise it will
create another problem on its self.
I hope this
three-day conference can bring about practical and
positive proposals for judicial reform and the
expansion of the rule of law and by these proposal
and suggestion we could go towards social, cultural,
political development of our country. And I think
our friends in this conference should keep in mind
that; their proposals and suggestions should cover
different aspects of our social life as we will not
be able to over come with the problems of
traditional practicing only by changing laws and we
should go further and bring changes to our
educational, political and cultural policies. At the
end I will appreciate again the efforts of WCLRF for
organizing such conference.
1.3. Mr. Fazel Ahmad
Manawi; Deputy Chief Justice; Supreme Court
Topic: Reaction of
justice to traditional practices:
I am very much happy
and proud of my contribution to the
struggle for women rights and I have
the honor that I am also part of the
network on fighting for women right;
although I will not accept the women right as a
political slogan I take it as my religious and moral
duty and I believe that even if the sisters here are
not fighting for their rights still we as religious
leaders need and have to fight for them and raise up
their voices and we have not started this fight
newly, it has been continuing from the beginning of
the Islam history; even from the time of first human
being (Adam) the violation of the rights was there
and we know that still we have this problem and it
will be continuing in the next generations as well,
but we have the duty to struggle against it and it
is one of the privileges that Islam has. If you read
the Islamic history you can find that one of the
main objectives of Islam is ensuring women right;
and before we raise our voices about; the Quran in
different verses has pointed out the issue, and even
we can say that the Quran is the beginner of the
fight for women right. It says in the Quran that in
the day of justice God will ask the girls that what
was your fault; Oh; poor girls that you were
punished, you were not deserved it, you were not
deserved to be buried alive; and also Quran says
that in the day of Justice (Qeamat) the abusers will
be asked why they did so, in very hard way. We as
Muslims believe that this world is not for ever and
one day every body will pass on from the world and
then we need to stand before God and face the God.
So if we are performing wrong deeds by the name of
religion, and we violate women rights using Islamic
slogans we have to answer before God. And it is
clear that all these wrong actions committed against
women are just misusing Islam as it had happened in
other religions too; if you see things done by the
name of Jewish , it doesn’t mean it has been
written in their book, it is only their judgment
and they way that people use the religious guidance.
If people and countries doing things with the
reference to their man made laws there is nothing to
object but it is not fair to do wrong things under
the name of religion.
So in short we can
say that from one side there is nothing against
women in Islam and in other hand Islam itself has
fought for the right of women.
Every body knows the
history of Islam; that when Islam came to Arab
society based on its principles, the shame of having
daughters had been lifted aside, and there were no
more the problem of burying girl alive. Hazrat Omar
was one of the first Islamic leaders and we see that
in his time he was famous for his justice and
honesty, but even he had buried his little girl
before coming to Islam. It has been said that Hazart
Omar had a daughter but as having daughter was a
matter of shame his wife didn’t tell him about; when
some body told him that “you are proud of being an
Arab Man but you have a daughter in your home, so
how you can be proud of being an Arab” he came home
and asked her wife about, her wife told him that yes
it is true but now she is so quit and you can never
kill her and she is now a growing up child. He asked
her wife to call her, Omar says; when she came and I
saw her she was really very beautiful and very quite
but I took her to the grave yard, and when I was
digging the grave and the dust was covering my face,
she was cleaning my face with her little hands, even
all this nice behavior of the poor child didn’t
change my decision and I buried her alive in the
grave. In most of the history books has been
written that Omar was laughing some times and some
times he was crying and when he was asked about; he
was saying I laugh because I am thinking how stupid
we were before coming to Islam and I cry because I
fear that God will never forgive me for what I have
done with my little child.
When Islam came it
put an end to all these actions, so now you can see
that the first struggle of Islam is to ensure women
rights and revives their dignity and honor. Also
prophet Muhammad was proud for having daughter and
if you look at Islamic philosophy of this issue, you
can see that Prophet Muhamad (PBUH) had no sons and
all his sons were dead in the childhood and the one
who brighten up her father life and the Prophet
Muhammad was proud of her was Ms. Fatima the only
daughter of Prophet Muhammad. May be it was a lesson
from the God to Muslims that the only child of
Prophet is a daughter; just put an end to the wrong
ideology of Arab on shame for having daughters and
not having a son for Prophet could not change any
thing and her daughter is the proud and honor of
Islamic history. But in our traditional society in
Afghanistan like the ignorance period of Arab people
violating women right, giving BAD is one the clear
examples of thousands of such hard actions and
practices; which we have to take this issue
seriously to think about. Giving BAD is not the only
mal-practice. We have many more from a very small
thing to bigger issues, as another example; when the
officials went to villages while ago to register the
population, they went to a family and asked how
people are in your family; how many men and how many
women? They got response; what is the name of
women??? So in this point the Mullah (religious
leader) of the village after pray told the villagers
“the Government is not a Muslim government and the
reason is they came and ask our wives names”; so you
can see how the society is bound with traditional
believes; that even the Mullah who is supposed to
guide people can not differentiate between islamic
and traditional thinking. But nobody can find any
word in Islam which prohibit calling the women names
as we know that the first Hadith in Islam is on the
name of Ayesha (the wife of Prophet Muhammad),
Fatima (daughter of Prophet Muhammad) and other
women relatives of him.
In another example
from my own life:
One day I had a very
strong headache I did lots of medical treatment but
it didn’t work so based on believe I went to Mullah
to treat me, when I went their and ask for
treatment, the Mullah kept quite and I said why he
is quite, he said to my friend who was accompanying
me, with very low voice, that “in order to do the
treatment I need to know his mother’s name, but I
don’t think it is good to ask her name”. and even
worse than that is that until my mother died I
didn’t know what her name was, and I just was
familiar with her surname which she was called with,
(as it is a tradition that no body should ask
women’s name), and when I knew that what beautiful
name she had I put the same name to my daughter, as
I want every body to know the name, and in fact it
was a very beautiful name that she had.
Meanwhile when we
are going to a marriage ceremony we see that it is
too difficult to call the bride with her name and
not even that when the bride asked to give her
consents to the marriage to two witnesses are coming
from the mullah side he has to see her directly and
openly and make sure that she is the one who gets
married, but in practice they put a curtain in front
of her and she has to confess very politely and with
low voice that she appoint X person as her
representative. And the reality is that even the
bride doesn’t need to appoint a representative and
she could go and be present in the marriage meeting
and announce her agreement openly. So it is the
traditions that people now get them as Islamic
principles and nobody dare to break such traditions.
This is why the
prophet Muhammad (PBUH) in his last speech to
Muslims (men and women who were present in his last
speech) says “O! Muslims! Be scared from the God in
relation to what you are doing with women.” and the
reason for this statement in his last advice which
had many important advices to Muslims is that the
Prophet knew that still there were violations in
regard of women rights and still there were people
who are against women.
So my suggestion to
you all is one, you have to be very practical and
careful of what you are doing to defend women which
my self is also contributor to that, and I promised
to many of the sisters that I will work with you and
help to find solutions to the problems. As we are
Muslims and believe that we have to be accountable
to God for what we are doing, thus if we are not
going to the right way and if we are doing wrong
things we will be punished for that, for this reason
when we are trying to solve problems we need to
think properly and find the best way for it. My
second suggestion would be, that as I my self is
believe to defend women rights and for that we
should push for legal orders and solutions which can
distinguish between right and wrong traditions. But
it is not the only way to solve problems and to
defend women rights and in fact it is the last
solution, as an example if a woman have been given
to BAD in a remote area of Badakhshan province, do
you think only by punishing the doers according to
law we will be able to solve her problem? No it is
not the way, as we are punishing every day the
numbers of criminals but the crimes are continuing.
Thus I am saying it is the last option and solution
and before that lets bring the trust among the
public that giving BAD is wrong and it has damaging
impacts; and this could be done through joint
efforts of religious leaders, media, conducting
workshops…and then if it didn’t work we can use
punishments.
Anyway today I left
the meeting of the high council of religious leaders
and came here and it shows how much we are committed
to fight against women rights violations and this
struggle should not be like our efforts to eliminate
drugs and instead the drugs cultivation is
increasing every day, we should not do things which
can damage women life instead.
Thanks
1.4. Dr. Rangeen
Dadfar Spanta, Political

Science Professor in
German University and guest teacher in Kabul
University
Topic: Traditional
practices and society:
Ladies and
gentlemen, I am happy to have the opportunity to talk
to you in my beloved country, As you know my
profession is in political theory
and science from an
international perspective and of course women
rights and issues is part of the international
relations I would forward few words but still
forgive me if there were any mistake or shortcoming
in my sayings.
What is clear that
violation to women right has been continuing through
out the history of human being, this is not only in
Afghanistan and nor in Islamic countries, even in
the most advanced European countries like Sweden and
Norway, women don’t have equal rights and they can
not find their place and position as equal human
beings. Most of the violation in the most advanced
countries applied on women and the women movements
and women networks should fight against what is
called obstacles to the moral principles in both
west and east world. Because with out widespread
struggles and without putting a question mark
towards the traditional practices applied on women
over centuries, access to equal right between men
and women is not possible.
Creating an
environment of respect to democracy and governance
building is not only able with the help of foreign
countries; it is a process of social movement
according to the national values and historical
values of a country, and it is one of the points
that women in our country should consider.
If we see the
development on women rights from the first
international conference on women right year 1975,
we can realize that there has been improvements and
women in different countries got access to some of
their fundamental rights, for example in north
Europe women have improvements in political, social
and cultural affairs. Even they can not address the
violence in the mind set of men and society.
Although their have
been policies and programs undertaken by Governments
in the last three decades in the area of education,
capacity building, expansion of literacy; in the
under development countries like Hindustan, and some
of the Islamic countries still the rate of
illiteracy is very high especially among women and
to say it differently, women comprise the most
illiterate, abused, and with minimum opportunities
in the area of access to the education. But this is
not the fault of a religion or religious believes,
it is the fault of our social and political
relationship which rooted from a position of power
which in turn have its roots in traditional
practices and believes; that exist very powerfully
in our communities and it has to be changed.
When we are talking
of violence we must remember that the violence has
different types; the physical abuse and violence
which men are famous for in the East and very
commonly the use their physical power to abuse their
wives and not only wives but all women in the
family. That is why although the violence has a root
in both East and West but the East is more visible
in this regards. But still in Germany 32% of women
are physically abused, this is a fact and figure
that we might not believe, while many are talking
about democracy and equality in these countries. In
the university that I am working only 13% of the
professors are women and the rest is men, and you
see that the story which is telling every where is
not true and the issue that violence is particular
for Muslim countries and societies are not true, in
fact women in other societies also don’t have a
better situation.
With all the
improvements and changes happened in the world of
technology and economy women are hopeful that their
situation will also be improved but this rarely
happened to become a reality. Because in a self
sufficient society women are also engage in
activities like gardenary, animal husbandry… and it
helps them to earn income but with improving the
systems and machinery like computers and etc which
needs especial professionalism and most of the
skills in this regard is with men, the movements
from village to city is increasing and, the family
economy becomes weak and as a result the women who
had relatively fair economical situation before,
with the reasons that they are illiterate and are
not familiar with technology (this issue is common
in Africa) they lose their economical value in the
society and the face a double violence in their
societies, and this system is applied on women even
in the most advanced countries; as the women working
hours are 16 when the working time for us in
universities (the men) are 8 hours and even due when
we go home everything should be ready for us, there
should be tea and dinner and every thing ready.
In another different
view the main contributing factor of violence
against women in some of the societies like
Hindustan (it is very common in Hindustan) is the
lack of women access to education, skill building
opportunities and proper food and the reason is that
the girls and women are seen as a economical cost
and lost for the family; that is why if you see the
children in such societies you see that the boys
have more healthy faces than girls. Because the food
should be served first for boys and in this way the
families are creating the environment of violence
for their own children. When the girls and women are
beaten and it becomes a routine action in the family
then the violence becomes stronger and common in the
society. And it is clear that a person whose rights
have been violated can become the violators of
others rights as well.
I remember that in
our society when a child is admitted to school the
first word from the mount of father to the teacher
is that “sir; the meat of my child is yours and I
only need the bones” (it means you can beat my child
and punish him/her as much as you want). And I
remember when my father told that I was scared too
much and I remember that the first day when the
teacher came told as “people call me Juma’ee Be
Khuda” (it means a person who is strong and even not
recognizing the God) and we small children were so
scared. We went to the place that we should have
been receiving love and kindness, but our first
experience started with violence and abuse. And when
a person starts its first experience with violence,
then the violence becomes a very common issue for
him/her and this violation will be extended from
family to school, university and the society and
such reality is very common and well known in
traditional societies where there is no any value
for asking the logic of any action and nobody ask
that why, when, what; the circle of violation moves
around and gets bigger every time and creates more
violence. As when I started the university in the
first day when the teacher entered the class around
200 mature and educated people (the students) stood
up and we named it a tradition, meanwhile in the
family traditional rules when a guest comes to your
home every body need to stay awake until the guest
is awake, even if the poor child has exam tomorrow
and we call it tradition and if he/ she has exam
tomorrow they have to stay till 10 – 11 o’clock at
night with the uncle coming from a province and it
is itself a structured violence and the continuation
of such practices made it so common and part of our
life. And because men are in a position of power and
they believe that they are stronger than women; in
most of the time they become the violator but the
medical science has proven that women are stronger
than men as they live longer than men and they face
less incidents of heart attack and diabetes… and the
only situation which women are facing problem more
than men are headache and the normal death. So by
this reasons the story of weak human being regarding
women is not true and it is a man made story and
that is the reason that women are thinking like men,
dressing like them… it is as if you see the famous
women in the world like Indera Gandi, and other
powerful women they all tried to behave like men and
tried to hidden their women nature, which is the
main problem when we want to fortify the women as
women. But with all what was said the violence
against women has a strong root in the traditional
practices, which is strongly present in our society.
There are different
cultural patterns in different parts of the country
and world, for example there are certain customs and
traditions in south of Afghanistan that are not
observed in north or in Kabul, and there are customs
and traditions in north of the country, for example
if you go to somebody’s house in northern
Afghanistan, the host brings food instead of tea,
but in west of Heart host brings tea to the guests.
But with all these customs and traditions there are
some forms of violence against women, which preclude
them form taking part in civil society. Even in the
modern society, as I mentioned before, structural
barriers exist that preclude women form having equal
rights with men and it is much more intense in
societies like ours.
Let me mention some
other problems too; one of which is women
participation in national economic processes. If we
possess a national economy, which we don’t have
right now, as the economy of the country is not
nation wide yet, women are under dual pressure both
in private and public sectors, i.e. they work both
at home and outside home, and they don’t have time
for cultural development issues. Therefore, women
are deprived of their basic rights.
This dual situation
is extensive in our society. Women cannot go to
school because of insecurity, lack of cultural and
moral values among people, and in many cases women
cannot go to school and university simply due to
shortage of universities and collages in the
country.
Most fathers would
not allow their daughters to go to Kabul for
studying in the university, but boys are allowed.
Girls should marry and go to husband’s home. This is
a reason for inequality between men and women. In
Europe mean age for women is 4 years higher than
that of men, despite the common saying that men are
stronger than women. But in developing countries
women have much worse health status due to lack of
health facilities. Women are given less attention
and are brought to doctors less often. Violence
prevents cultural, political and social development
of people, and makes them totalitarian. People in
traditional societies who grew up in democratic way
of thinking are like bicycle riders who push the
pedals and bend against the wind coming towards
them, for example if you say that the Education
Ministry does not have a good building they will say
that the honorable Education Ministry does not have
a beautiful building. People who were grown in
violence have observant language. Contemporary
societies have various treaties that are created for
some traditions. The problem is that can we commit
ourselves to these treaties? I think that the first
step in Afghanistan was creating the constitution
for Afghanistan, in which some of the cultural and
religious principles are included, and some of
modern global principles which are in harmony with
our cultural principles and values are included too.
We can document it as a written treaty. Contemporary
treaties are documents and provide the opportunity
for participation in civil society. The civil
society is a society with law.
In American and
European societies, the society is divided into
three basic element, that include Economy, which is
out of people’s control, Government, which executes
the power and mediates among people and is not
controlled by the people, and Society. Society and
the government should have an economy. When the
society gets out of economic or government control
as a result of struggles for civil society, it was
set forth that the society should be something other
than economic and political aspects of the
government. The citizens should have power, i.e. a
citizen must be independent, and should contribute
voluntarily in the society, based on civil society
values such as brotherhood, cooperation, solidarity.
These organizations that are created according to
voluntary work and based on above mentioned values
may cause growth and development of civil society
organizations and the duty of these organizations
would be bringing back the control of society under
the economic part of the government.
The vacuum in
justice, equality and cultural context of the
economic part of the government need solidarity. For
now, in a society in which about half of it do not
participate in the daily political and civil
activities due to cultural, traditional and belief
problems, existence of a civil society is not much
realistic, but we are at the threshold of the
process of civil society, and this is a long
process, and will continue until human beings exist,
and will extend. Women slowly become independent as
their education level rise and the economical
dependence decrease. Therefore, with these steps the
society can grow to a civil society and this is a
process that we are at the beginning of it.
1.5.
Speech of Mr Qiamuddin Kaschaff, Director Public
security dept. of the Supreme Court of Afghanistan,
on customs and traditions from Islamic point of
view:

As with other
countries of the world, in which Women rights are
given in some extent, Islam gives women civil as
well as spiritual value too. A person asked the
prophet that who should be most respected, and
the prophet answered it is the mother who must
be respected most. This is the saying of the
prophet, not a writer, not a poet, not a scientist and
not a philosopher. There is a verse in the Holly Quran
which says “his saying is nothing but revelations we
sent him”. He has given 3 times more rights to
mother than father. In which part of the world women
rights are 3 times more than that of men? Of course
there is no place where this can be observed. Only
in Islam this kind of rights are given to women. The
prophet ordered Omar to seek blessing of a person in
Madina, who was called Wais Qarani. Omar said he
wasn’t a Sahabi (person who had talked with the
prophet), and this person had not seen the prophet.
But the prophet ordered him to seek his blessing and
to tell him that the prophet had mentioned him. He
went and saw this man, and told him that “you never
talked to the prophet but he ordered us to seek your
blessings”. He said “my mother was very old and weak
and I couldn’t go to see the prophet because my
mother needed me”. Please note that how much the
prophet gives importance to respecting women, and
prefers serving mothers to attending prophet’s
meetings. Islam is full of these fine cases.
Iqbal says “Islam
has no flaws in it, it is us who bring the flaws”.
We shouldn’t feature Islam by what Moslems do, but
we should study Islam as it is.
Mahr (marriage
portion) is women’s right, and is mentioned in the
Holly Quran and is called Qantar (unlimited goods).
Omar was delivering a speech on Mahr and was saying
that it was better to have the Mahr lower. But a
woman raised her voice and said that “O Omar, you
are wrong! God has given us Qantar, why you are
asking us to drop this amount?” Omar accepted her
objection and said that she was right and “Omar was
wrong”, despite he was the Caliph of all Moslems in
the world, and could reject her objection.
Bad traditions and
customs exist even in the 21st century
and some of them are worse than those of medieval
era. It would not be correct to link every wrong and
had tradition with Islam. In Islam a woman has the
right to ask her husband to provide a nursing woman
for her child, and the husband has to provide it
without hesitation. Even if the wife asks for money
for her breast milk, husband must pay for it. Is
there this kind of rights for women elsewhere?
Providing food, home, cloths etc for women is the
responsibility of men, while women have the right to
work and make capital of their own. In Islam it is
not said that women should stay in their homes, but
they have the right to work. In 1978 I was with
Mufti Mahmood in Pakistan, when somebody asked his
about women rights. He said there are many books
written on this subject, but I will summarize it in
one sentence, I hope you will understand it. Women
have that much rights in Islam that if these right
were given to them properly, I Mufti Mhamood would
ask God to make me a woman! It was really a good
answer and he said that if women rights which are
entitled to them in Islam are given to them, women
would enjoy the most comfortable life in the world.
Now, some people
sell women for money. Is it in Islam? Certainly not.
These people make a bad reputation for Islam and
this money is haram (illegal) in Islam, as is bribe.
The father does not have the right to take money in
exchange of his daughter. The bride has the right to
use the marriage portion. She can give it to her
father, can give it to some one else or just throw
it away, or keep it. Is there this tradition in
Islam that when some one commits murder or kidnaps
as woman then gives his women as an exchange for his
crimes, when the jirga (peoples’ gathering) ask him
to do so? Certainly it is not in Islam. Isn’t it
burying her alive? Isn’t this girl under pressure
for the rest of her life? And she is insulted and
said to her that she was brought there as and
exchange. Islam does not support but condemn the act
of giving a lady in exchange of her father or
brother’s crimes. This is certainly against Islamic
values.
Also, exchange
marriage, in which girls are exchanged for girls or
money, is against Islamic teachings. Women are human
beings and are not for exchange. Most of problems
among families are because of this kind of
marriages.
In Afghanistan
women are given freedom, which is much more than you
would expect, but it is different. In Afghanistan
women are seen as respectful people. The limitations
set out by Islam are to protect their respect,
social values and human rights. Islam broke all
negative and bad traditions and customs which
existed before, such as burying girls alive, sell
them in markets, or having women as house maids.
Islam is sent by God to guid us throughout our
lives. Every equipment is supplied with a user’s
manual, in which the ways to operate that equipment
is shown. If the equipment is used without
consulting with the manual it may be damaged. God
has created us and has sent us a guiding manual,
which is Holly Quran. If we follow its instructions,
we would have a good and respectful life, and if we
do not use the guide, we will be losers.
I was the deputy
speaker in the constitution loya jirga, and there
were a great number of women there. They put me
under pressure and said that they wanted more time
and opportunity to speak. The same thing was from
men too. I’m proud of women for their speeches,
activities and responsibilities. They are a bright
part of our society. 42 % of women in Afghanistan
voted, some of whom were not given permission by
their families to work out of home, but men did not
stop them from voting. This is a fact, and please
look at the constitution and see what is gives you.
At the end I would
like to thank Women and Children Rights Research
Organization for holding this conference.
1.6.
Speech of Dr Zekria, member Judiciary and Justice
Reform Commission, on traditions in comparison with
law.
I would like to
start my speech from this point, that the first
relation which links humanity together is society.
What is society made of? Society is make of family,
nation, tribe, etc.
In a society where
there is no law traditions and customs are used
as replacement of law to some extent.
Traditions and customs are based on beliefs.
There is the question of why societies need law?
The answer is that societies can go forward with
law.
Freedom does not
mean that humans are subject to responsibilities,
but humans should be ruling the responsibilities.
The person who rules the responsibilities is always
successful. God made human beings the noblest
creature, so that it becomes the ruler of the
responsibility, and humans are given authority so
that responsibility is governing the society. It
means that there must be laws so that by enforcing
them the society progress and develop. The other
pillar of the society is enforcing and monitoring
the law, so that all moral and social laws monitor
traditions. For this pillar two monitors are needed,
one is external which is police, and the other is
internal which is God. Some countries have separated
their law from religion.
If you have noticed
when a crime is committed or a murder is committed,
murderer’s family is always seen as the murderer in
the eyes of the murdered family. In fact these
violence create tradition and sometimes the violence
can destroy a society.
As the speakers
said, we are moving from a simple society towards a
complex one, in which every individual has
responsibility. Some of traditions are enforced as
laws. Police was responsible for monitoring, but now
military, security and executive forces govern the
society in a complex manner. Therefore, the 2
phenomena we needed for the society were:
legislative and judicial forces. Despite existence
of Shariah in Afghanistan, the government has not
been able to enforce it in the country. Today, there
are traditions in our country that do not relate to
Islam. The other factor that had negative impact on
our society has been more than 20 years of war and
conflict, and tyranny and violence was ruling the
country. We have another problem too. Now we are not
in isolation from the world as we were 100 years
ago. Now we have links with other parts of the world
and the world is looking at us, and affects us. The
effects had their influence on the way we wear
cloths, and our livelihoods. We had a strong
cultural background but today western culture is
dominating our society day by day.
When we try to
bring reforms in our laws we have to know which of
them are related to our culture and which is not, as
Mr Manawi and Kachaff said.
We must recognize
our good traditions and keep them. According to
statistical data in the world, 2 out of 3 marriages
break away, every minute a woman is abused or raped
in some western countries. But fortunately in our
country, due to good traditions and customs less men
divorce their wives and respect marriage
relationships, which in my opinion a good tradition.
It should be pointed
out that violence against women is not exclusive to
Islamic societies. At the end I would like to
encourage who established this organization. This is
the way to struggle because you have to take your
rights, nobody will give it to you.
Thank you
1.7. Speech of Ms
Amina Afzali, member Human Rights Independent
Commission, on traditions from international law
point of view for women.

Greetings my
brothers and sisters, and thanks for Women and
Children Rights Research Organization who have held
this conference. We really benefit from these
conferences. The subject given to me was women
rights violations in bad traditions. We do not have
any problem with the present laws in our country and
society, but some of our laws should be refined so
that bad traditions can be stopped. If our
constitution and civil laws are not enforced, they
remain on paper. We are Moslems but unfortunately we
never follow Islam, especially our society conduct
is un-islamic. One of the bad traditions here is
forced marriages. In Islam forced marriage is
unlawful. If both sides, i.e. bride and groom are
not agreed with the marriage, then this marriage is
not legal. Today, most of the problems which end up
in violence, according to reports coming to Human
Rights Commission, are rooted in forced marriages. I
want to talk about present situation, we will see if
the bad tradition roots in our society and history
and what place is given by Islam to women.
With the start of
Interim government
and approval of
constitution positive
changes in the
constitution came into
view. I was one of
the members for the
Constitution
Commission. When we
wrote our opinion
on paper we did not
believe that this
could be taken in to con-
sideration, because
the traditions have
strong influence in
the society. It will
take a long time
that changes take place.
I think the laws
alone cannot be enough for stopping violence against
women. We must increase level of knowledge in the
society by public awareness, and provide economic
growth for women. If women are given part in home
economy it will be a good pace for them. Women in
home have responsibility of managing the house and
look after children. If we analyze it this is a big
problem, that we can relate it to economic matters,
but unfortunately men in our society do not think
about this and always say that women must cook and
manage the house. While the prophet helped his wife
in home, it is a taboo in our society that a man
washes dishes or cleans the house. Most men do not
respect their wives despite this division of works.
When the man comes home from work expects his wife
to respect him. He should also respect his wife
because she also worked hard in home. This brings
friendship between them. But most men expect too
much form their wives, which eventually cause
violence.
When the level of
knowledge in the society increase and men and women
understand their responsibilities in the family,
these problems will disappear. I wanted to give you
brief reports of human rights abuses during the
years of interim and transitional governments of
Afghanistan. These abuses are registered in the
Independent Human Rights Commission but our data are
neither accurate nor proven, because most of women
in our society do not have access to human rights
commission. Most of the cases referred to us are
from Kabul, from which more than 60 cases are forced
marriages, some of which ended up with divorce and
about 100 cases in the last 6 months were deferred
to public courts by the commission. Some of cases
were solved by negotiations with both sides. Some of
women think it is not right to go to the courts or
human rights commission, and accept suffering in bad
conditions. Therefore, it is possible that a great
number of the problems cannot be registered.
Regarding the
problems of abuse in provinces we will talk about
eastern province of Nangarhar and western province
of Herat. For example, in Herat where people have
high cultural level, suicide among women and girls
is high. In the last 6 months more than 180 cases of
suicide is registered form Herat, from which about
100 cases were self burning and some the cases were
suicide by toxic drugs. About 70% of these cased
ended up with the death of the victims. The reason
was either they died before they reached hospital or
they were not brought to hospital al all. These data
show the extent of violence against women. The
registered cases form Jalalabad show that 80 suicide
cases by opium, form which 70 of them died. 39 cases
of self burning and many cases of beating were
registered. These data show how much violence is
committed against women and they were forced to
commit suicide. There are many cases that the
husband became angry with his wife because she had
put color on her hair, a wife was blinded by her
husband because she looked at some one, and a friend
to me that a man cut his wife’s lips because she
kissed her son-in-law.
These cases were
registered during this year, and show the degree of
violence against women, which is caused by low level
of knowledge among women and bad tradition in the
society, because most women are not aware of their
rights. At the end I hope that holding these
conferences help women to raise their voices and
solve their proble
1.8. Speech of Ms
Najia Zewari, representative of UNIFEM, on UN
commitments of women rights.
We are part of a
historical process
As we are at the
threshold of fighting
Violence against
women week, struggle against
bad traditions and
customs is part of this fight;
it would be rational
to look at the global events
in relation with
women rights, and mention some
of historical
documents and events in this context:
-
Women’s day was
marked for the first time on March 8th
1911.
-
in 1946 UN
commission on women conditions was established.
-
In 1946 UN Human
Rights declaration was approved.
-
In 1949
convention on prohibition of human traffic and
prostitution was approved, which was enforced
since July 25, 1991.
-
On December 20,
1952 treaty of Political Rights of Women was
approved by theUN, and was enforced since July
7, 1954.
-
On January 29,
1957 UN approved a treaty for the citizenship of
married women, which was enforced since August
11, 1958.
-
On November 25,
1960 Miraol Sisters political activists were
killed by the dictator Torjilo in Dominican
Republic. Since 1981 day of violence against
women is celebrated worldwide.
-
On December 14,
1960 a treaty against discrimination in
education was approved, which was enforced since
May 22, 1962.
-
In 1961
Paraguay was the last Latin American country
which gave voting right to women.
-
On November 7,
1962 treaty on youngest age for marriage was
approved, and was enforced since December 9,
1964.
-
In 1964 treaty
on employment was approved and is enforced since
1966.
-
In 1967 Iran
approved a law which allows women to support the
family, and work without husband permission.
-
On April 22 to
May 13 1968 International conference on human
rights was held in Iran.
-
In early 1970
marches called “re-take the nights” were
commenced for the first time by women.
-
On December 14,
1974 convention on protecting the women and
children in emergency situations and military
conflicts was approved.
-
In 1975 this
year was named Year of Women.
-
On March 4-8
first international court on crime against women
was held in Belgium.
-
In 1976 UN
decade for women began.
-
On December 18,
1979 convention on eradication of discrimination
against women was approved by UN assembly and
was enforced since December 3, 1981.
-
Form 6 to 15
April international workshop on fight against
traffic and sexual slavery of women was held in
Holland.
-
In 1985 a treaty
against torture and other forms of tyranny and
on commutation in punishment was approved and
enforced since 1987.
-
International
Women conference was held in Kenya from 15 to 26
July 1985.
-
In December 6,
1984 in Canada an angry man killed 14 women
technicians because they were working in a field
belonged to men.
-
From November 25
to December 10 the first ever 16 day campaign on
violence against women was held globally and the
women’s human rights campaign started.
-
In 1992 rape was
used as a war weapon, whose victims were
thousands of women in former Yugoslavia.
-
In New Zealand
100 years of women struggle for their right to
vote in the political elections in that country
was celebrated. New Zealand was the first
country to give women right to vote.
-
On 15-25 June,
1993 International Human Rights conferences and
International Court on human rights violations
against women was held in Austria and about
500000 signatures were collected and submitted
to whir.
-
On October 6,
1993 with integration of Bahamas in the
convention on obliteration of discrimination
against women of Latin America and Caribbean, it
was the first region that all of the countries
signed the convention.
-
In December 1993
UN general assembly approved a resolution on
violence against women.
-
On December 20,
1993 UN general assembly approved a resolution
on appointing a human right commissioner. UN
general assembly asked the commissioner to
prepare working plan for the human rights decade
on education to be announced in 49th
session of the general assembly.
-
In 1957 in the
fourth international women conference, UN
announced the year 1975 as the international
year for women.
-
The first
international women conference was held in
Mexico from June 16 to July 2. Its theme was
Equality, Development and Peace.
-
UN announced
1976 to 1985 as the decade for women.
-
The second
international women conference (mid women
decade) was held in Copenhagen from July 14 to
26, 1980.
-
In 1985 third
international women conference was held in
Nairobi, Kenya from July 15 to 26. Its aim was
strategies for future development of women
towards 204.
-
Forth
international women conference was held in
Peking, China from September 4-15. Its outcome
was Peking Declaration and practice of Peking
Movement.
-
Special part of
UN general assembly for women (2000):
Gender equality, development and peace for
21st century in New York held on June
5-9. Its outcome was a political resolution and
related documents. More measures and initiatives to
make Peking Movement operational.
Annex 2:
Women and Children Legal Research Foundation (WCLRF)
Declaration of the
Conference on
“Impact of traditional Practices on Afghan Women”
22 – 24 November 2004
Kabul-Afghanistan
Any kind of violence against women is condemned!
We, the participants
of the Conference on “Assessment of Traditions’
Impact on Afghan Women”, representing almost all
of Afghanistan and accepting that all around the
world women and girls are the most vulnerable
people; and in the memorial of all those women and
girls who have been the victim of violence; having
Islam’s supportive and strong position as the main
backbone; also by considering the support of Afghan
Constitution and all other prevailing laws and
regulations; keeping in mind the commitment of
Afghan Government to the International Declaration
of Human Rights, Islamic Declaration of Human
Rights, The convention on elimination of
discrimination against women and other valuable
international documents regarding the support for
women’s equal rights; stating that most of Afghan
local traditions have become the main factors to the
propagation of violence in Afghanistan;
understanding that dissemination of information
about the impact of traditions on afghan women under
the effective and continuous support of the
Government and Judicial institutions could become a
key element in decreasing and elimination of one
type of violence against women; and with the
attention to the importance of women and girls
participation in the social life of societies;
conclude the following articles as the main demands
of women and girls for reducing violence against
them, and ask for solemn attention from the part of
government, its related institutions and
international communities in this regard:
1- Since,
setting and enforcing the law has a
determinant role in establishing the citizens’
rights and freedom, it is necessary that all actions
and movements which, in the name of tradition, are
imposed on afghan women and girls should be
considered as the source of violence and declared as
violation of the law and the perpetrators be
punished.
2-
As the highest justice implementing authority,
the judiciary system in cooperation of
other institutions concerning the citizen rights,
based on legal and jurisprudential adjudications
should pay an axial role in elimination of those
traditions which are determined as the source of
violence and the violators must be accordingly
penalized.
3-
The role of the executive authority,
in particular the law enforcement institutions such
as police, prosecuting authority, Ministry of
Justice and other related stakeholders, is very
effective and constructive for the implementation of
law and detection, persecution, inspection of crimes
originated from traditions; consequently, these
authorities must take serious steps to prevent the
tradition based violence against women and girls and
arrest the criminals.
4- As the
local Jirgas ( traditional gathering
of afghan communities in southern Afghanistan) and
Shuras ( local counseling board made
up of elders, influencing members and trustees of
the community) are the most important structures to
implement and enforce the traditions and the
decisions and decrees made by them is effectively
executed, we suggest:
a) It is
convenient that for the choosing implementation
approaches and decision making, during the Jirgas; a
specific framework and effective principles be
projected, based on which the people included in the
Jirgas feel responsible and committed towards their
decisions.
b) In order
to pave the way for reducing and elimination of
violence against women, their participation in the
above mentioned structures should be facilitated
using the different existing programs as National
Solidarity Program
5-
Emphasizing on our people’s strong religious
beliefs and the prominent stance of
religious scholars in elucidating public opinion, we
request from all Scholars and clergy men that:
a) They help
people to broaden their view and making them
understand the existing differences among the
traditions and religious believes; and through
elimination tradition based violence, they support
afghan women and girls.
b) They
explain canonical rights of women and girls to
afghan society and they emphasize on the obligation
to respect these rights.
6-
Media has a particular role in raising
public awareness in defending the rights of
individuals and groups; knowing that women and girls
are bearing much violence induced by wanted and
unwanted traditions; we aspire that Afghan Media
provide a support for this by undefended group which
has been victimized by local traditions broadcasting
the voice of afghan women and girls.
7-
Literacy and access to education
is the most basic means to support women and girls
against the violence; so we are confident that any
kind of measures taken for the preparation of
facilities to improve education and literacy among
women and families, it would reduce the violence
many fold.
8-
Seeing that poverty is considered one
of the basic factors of violence and in addition,
lack of access to material advantages make women and
girls more needy and undefended; we have to take
some specific and defined initiations to make sure
the economical independence of women and girls.
9- Until
now, national human rights supporting institutions,
civil society, national and international
non-governmental organizations and UN agencies have
played an important and effective role in
elimination of encroachments and violations against
various vulnerable groups and in particular women;
now since these organizations and institutions being
extensively active inside afghan society, and by
using their experience, can release women and girls
from all violations caused by local traditions and
customs.
10- We, the
participants of the conference on ‘Assessment of
Traditions Impact on Afghan Women’ representing
various provinces and gathered in Kabul the capital
of our country, have ratified this ten-article
declaration and look forward to seeing the
responsible authorities provide the needed support,
for afghan women and girls against the traditions
causing violence, based on the proposed suggestions
in this declaration.
|